MEPs sank Europe's new protections for small investors by 14 votes, so your bank's commission rules stay as they are
On 12 November the European Parliament voted down, 300 to 286, the deal with EU governments on new retail-investment rules: a client-interest test on adviser commissions, a value-for-money bar on products and oversight of 'finfluencers'. The update to the key information document did pass.
The EU’s new rules for people who put their savings into funds, investment-linked insurance or shares have fallen at the European Parliament. On Thursday 12 November, MEPs rejected the deal struck with member states on the retail investment strategy by 300 votes to 286, with 23 abstentions, Agence Europe reported. Fourteen votes did it.
It was meant to be one of the pieces that gets more Europeans investing instead of leaving cash idle. Now it is in limbo.
What would have changed for retail investors?
Three things above all, according to the Parliament’s own file on the law.
Commissions. When a bank or broker sells you a fund, it can pocket a slice of that product’s charges. The deal would have made it show the sale served your interest and that the advice actually benefited you, and would have split those payments out from other fees in what you are told.
Value for money. Products whose costs aren’t justified by what they deliver would have been kept off the market, judged against benchmarks set by the EU supervisors (ESMA for markets, EIOPA for insurance). Comparing costs, charges and performance would have been easier.
Finfluencers. Firms paying social-media finance influencers would have needed a written agreement, their contact details, and responsibility for what they say.
What stays the same?
Almost everything. Today’s rules under MiFID II, which already require firms to check a product is suitable for you, stay in force. Even if the deal had passed, it would only have applied about two and a half years after publication.
The other half of the package did pass, 311 to 261: an overhaul of the key information document, the short sheet (three pages at most) you must be given before buying a packaged investment product.
Why did it fail, and what happens next?
The Socialists, Greens and the Left voted against, joined by some EPP and conservative MEPs, including the EPP’s own negotiator, Markus Ferber. The fiercest fight was over commissions. The rapporteur, France’s Stéphanie Yon-Courtin, said the defeat delays the finfluencer rules and new tools for supervisors.
The European Commission says it will consider its next steps. Three routes are open: approve the member states’ text as it stands, let the file die, or send it back to the economic affairs committee for up to four months of renegotiation.
In the meantime, the question the law wanted to make standard is one you can ask at the counter today: how much does the bank earn for selling me this? With inflation eating the interest on most savings, knowing what investing costs matters as much as knowing what it pays.
Image: Zsolt Bodnár / Pexels