Moana live-action opens soft: 45 million dollars for a 250-million film
Disney's live-action Moana opened to an estimated 40-45 million dollars in the US, well below hopes for a 250-million-dollar production. Critics gave it 35% on Rotten Tomatoes.
The flesh-and-blood Moana isn’t sailing the way Disney dreamed. The live-action remake, which hit cinemas on Friday, is tracking towards a 40-45 million dollar opening weekend in the United States — well short of the 60-plus million the studio hoped for, and an uncomfortable number for a film that cost 250 million before a cent of marketing.
How much did the live-action Moana make on opening?
Weekend estimates point to 40-45 million dollars in the US, after 4.5 million from Thursday previews. For context: the 2016 animated Moana opened to 57 million, and 2024’s Moana 2 rocketed to 140. In other words, the version with real actors — Catherine Laga’aia as Moana and Dwayne Johnson once again as Maui, now in person — is opening below the original it set out to remake, in a week that was supposed to belong to it on July’s release calendar.
Why is Moana falling short?
The reviews didn’t help: 35% on Rotten Tomatoes, below even Snow White (39%) and Aladdin (57%), and live-action remake fatigue is looking less like a theory every month. The summer is crowded too — Toy Story 5 opened with a franchise record a few weeks ago and is still hoovering families into cinemas. The film’s official page is on Disney’s site.
The good news for Disney? The weekend isn’t over, and international markets may soften the fall. The bad news: when audiences would rather rewatch the cartoon at home, the ocean doesn’t call — it refunds.
By Lucy Bennett
Image: Gage Skidmore / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)