Trump, Xi and Putin signed off on a nuclear pledge in Shenzhen. Ukraine didn't make the text
The three leaders met for about 90 minutes behind closed doors on the sidelines of APEC and released a four-point declaration: UN reform, more refined oil products, immunity for state officials with a warning to the International Criminal Court, and a pledge that a nuclear war 'cannot be won', with talks on nuclear risk. Neither Ukraine nor Iran is mentioned.
The first three-way meeting between the presidents of the United States, China and Russia ended in Shenzhen on Thursday with a sentence the world has heard before: a nuclear war “cannot be won and must never be fought”. Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin spent around an hour and a half behind closed doors on the sidelines of the APEC summit and took no questions afterwards.
What they produced is short. The China-Russia-US Heads of State Declaration toward Peace, released in full by Chinese state television, makes four commitments, and none of them names a war that is actually happening.
What does the Shenzhen declaration say?
Four things. As permanent members of the Security Council, the three countries commit to reforming the UN. They want more production and supply of refined petroleum products, for the sake of stable energy flows. They say state consent and immunity for state officials are “of paramount importance”, and that the International Criminal Court and similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction.
And, in the line that will get quoted most, they reaffirm that nobody wins a nuclear war and open a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and stopping proliferation. No date, no venue, no named team.
Is the nuclear war line new?
No. It is word for word what the five recognised nuclear-weapon states agreed in a joint statement in January 2022, published by the White House at the time. Less than two months later, Russia invaded Ukraine. What is new in Shenzhen is the format, three leaders in one room, and the promise to keep talking. Not the sentence.
What happened to Ukraine and Iran?
They stayed off the page. According to Russia’s TASS agency, Ukraine was the main subject of Trump and Putin’s one-to-one before the trilateral, and Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov called the atmosphere positive. None of it reached the final text, and at the time of writing the White House had not published its own account.
When we previewed the meeting, each capital was arriving in Shenzhen with a different agenda: Beijing talked strategic stability, Washington nuclear weapons and Iran, Moscow Ukraine. Judging by what ended up on paper, the agenda that commits nobody to anything won.
What is still open between Washington and Beijing?
Plenty. The US-China tariff truce runs out on 10 January, Trump said before the meeting that he wants China buying more American farm goods, and Xi, ahead of the meeting, called nuclear weapons a “sword of Damocles” that should be banned and destroyed. Today’s promised dialogue is the first place to find out whether that line is worth more than the 2022 one.
Image: The White House / Wikimedia Commons (public domain)