Sony wins £2bn PlayStation Store fight as UK tribunal rules it is not dominant
The Competition Appeal Tribunal unanimously threw out a claim brought for 12.2 million UK players, finding the right market is the whole console system, where PlayStation competes with Xbox and Nintendo.
Sony has won outright at the Competition Appeal Tribunal in London. In a unanimous judgment dated 17 November, the tribunal dismissed a collective claim brought on behalf of about 12.2 million UK PlayStation users, who were seeking some £1.49bn, or roughly £1.97bn with interest.
The fight was over the PlayStation Store. Digital games for a PlayStation console can only be bought there, and Sony typically keeps around 30% of the price. The claim, led by consumer campaigner Alex Neill, argued this was an abuse of a dominant position and that prices would otherwise have been about 20% lower.
What did the tribunal decide about the PlayStation Store?
Market definition decided it. The claimants focused on sales of digital PlayStation games and add-ons, where Sony is the only shop in town. The tribunal called that an unsafe basis and looked instead at the whole system: console, games and services, competing against Xbox and Nintendo.
On that view Sony is not dominant. The panel found that people buying a console can weigh up what they will spend on games later, heavy spenders above all, and that this keeps the company in check. Evidence about Sony’s model also mattered: it accepts low or even negative margins on consoles and recovers the money from games over time.
The judgment goes further still. Even on the claimants’ preferred market, it says, the alleged abuses were not made out and Sony’s margin was not shown to be excessive.
Is the case over?
Not quite. The tribunal will hold a hearing in the week of 14 December on costs and any application for permission to appeal. For now, UK players have nothing coming.
Does the ruling matter outside the UK?
It does not bind courts elsewhere, but similar cases exist. In Portugal, the consumer association Ius Omnibus filed a claim at the Competition Court in Santarém in August 2023, seeking up to €235m for PS4 and PS5 users over conduct going back to November 2013. We could not confirm what stage it has reached. In the Netherlands, a consumer foundation launched a similar campaign in 2025.
Sony’s arguments in London, and the way the tribunal accepted them, now give its lawyers a template for those fights. All this lands in a week when console owners are talking about little except GTA VI, the most-nominated game at The Game Awards, which arrives on Thursday.
By Oliver Grant
Illustrative · Photo: Pascal / Pexels