Was America's week of outages a cyberattack? The White House says no
Nine disruptions in six days, from Apple to the NSA, pushed Washington to respond. The intelligence chief and Marco Rubio describe separate incidents tied to patches, upgrades and ageing systems.
The White House said on Wednesday that America’s run of technology failures was not a cyberattack. “This is not a cyberattack, and this is not a coordinated effort by a nation state,” said Jay Clayton, the Director of National Intelligence. Marco Rubio, who is both Secretary of State and National Security Adviser, added that nothing suggests the incidents are related to one another.
That it needed saying at all comes down to the list. By our count there were nine significant disruptions between 12 and 17 November, across industries with little in common.
Which US services went down this week?
It began on 12 November, when Microsoft lost Outlook and Teams for more than a day. Workday’s HR and payroll tools struggled the next day, the same day the FAA grounded departures nationwide.
Monday belonged to the banks, with JPMorgan Chase, Bank of America and Wells Fargo customers having trouble logging in and moving money. United Airlines held flights that day too. Tuesday was the busiest of all: Apple (iCloud, Apple Pay, the App Store), Marriott, the brokerage Charles Schwab and the NSA’s classified internal network.
What caused each outage?
Where an explanation exists, it is technical and self-inflicted. Microsoft pointed to a network capacity upgrade. JPMorgan cited a software bug. Apple blamed an internal update, and the NSA described a “temporary degradation” linked to maintenance. United and Marriott say they see no sign of a cybersecurity problem.
Clayton’s summary was not exactly soothing. Systems need upgrades and patches, he said, and they do not always come back the way anyone expected.
Is the investigation over?
Not entirely. The FAA has narrowed its inquiry to routers at two remote sites, in Amarillo, Texas, and El Dorado, Arkansas, but the root cause is still being examined, and Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy says he asked the FBI to look at the equipment. Microsoft also still owes a final report.
So “no evidence of an attack” is today’s official position rather than the last word on every case. For now the simplest explanation is also the least cinematic one: a lot of old infrastructure being worked on at the same time.
By Oliver Grant
Image: National Security Agency / Wikimedia Commons (public domain)