Portuguese Navy clashes with court: judge threatens new fine for Chief of Naval Staff
The judge in the NRP Mondego state-secrets trial has again reprimanded the Portuguese Navy for obstructing proceedings and threatens Admiral Jorge Nobre de Sousa with a new fine.
The standoff between Portugal’s courts and its Navy escalated another notch this Friday. The judge presiding over the trial of three military personnel accused of violating state secrets, in the case linked to the NRP Mondego, once again reprimanded the branch for obstructing proceedings and warned that the Chief of Naval Staff, Admiral Jorge Nobre de Sousa, risks a fresh fine if witnesses fail to appear again.
Why does the Navy chief risk another fine?
Because the court no longer trusts the Navy’s notification chain. In June, the admiral was ordered to pay 816 euros after the branch failed to notify two military witnesses — a failure the Navy itself admitted was internal, while denying any disrespect towards the court. Now the judge has decided not to take chances: witnesses will be summoned by letter, by telephone and through the Military Judicial Police, with the hearing set for 23 September. If the machine jams again, the sanction repeats.
Who paid the 816-euro fine?
That is the second front of the controversy. Lawyer Garcia Pereira maintains the fine was paid through an account at the IGCP — the agency that manages the state treasury — which would mean public money settling a personal sanction. The Navy insists the opposite: the payment came from the admiral’s personal bank account, and he denies any use of public funds. The doubt, however, hung over the courtroom and is unlikely to evaporate on its own.
For the government and parliament, the case is one more institutional headache in an already loaded political season — the State of the Nation debate is set for the 16th, and friction between the courts and the armed forces is not a headline any executive wants. Between military discipline and judicial authority, September will tell whether the Navy has learned to deliver letters.
Image: Rakoon / Wikimedia Commons (CC0)