Apple pulled Telegram worldwide over child abuse material. It was back within hours
App review found content violating Apple's rules. Telegram deleted it, banned the account behind it, and the app returned to the store.
For a few hours on Tuesday, Telegram was simply gone from the App Store. Not a regional block, not a server problem. The app stopped being available to download anywhere in the world, with no warning and no immediate word from Apple.
The explanation came afterwards, and it is serious. Apple’s review team found child sexual abuse material in the app, a direct breach of its store rules. The company confirmed it had removed Telegram while the matter was dealt with, and restored it once the developer deleted the content and banned the user who had posted it.
Who noticed and who did not
Only new installs were affected. Anyone who already had Telegram on an iPhone carried on using it throughout. What was suspended was the download and, presumably, updates. For existing users the whole episode passed largely unseen.
Apple states a zero-tolerance position on this category of content in its App Store Review Guidelines, and temporary removal is the standard tool: rather than negotiate, it takes the app off the shelf and puts it back once the problem is fixed. Telegram has tripped over this exact rule before, spending several days out of the store in 2018 for the same reason.
The real subject here is moderation
Telegram grew by championing large channels, encryption and a light touch. That posture attracts users, and it inevitably also attracts people who want to post what no other platform will host. Regulatory pressure on the company is not new, and founder Pavel Durov is facing legal proceedings that put the platform’s moderation squarely at the centre.
For Apple the episode reinforces an argument it makes when defending control of the store: this is what a curated marketplace does when it finds something. The same logic was in play when San Francisco demanded Apple and Google drop AI ‘nudify’ apps. The difference this time is that the removal came from Apple itself, and took hours rather than months.
By Oliver Grant
Image: Yuri Samoilov / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)