Lisbon court lets a protest tent stay in Rossio until 24 November (one tent, not the camp)
Lisbon's Administrative Court ruled on Sunday that the 12.30am cut-off for demonstrations is neither absolute nor automatic, and allowed protester Renata Cambra to stay overnight in Rossio with a tent until the day of the final 2027 budget vote. The ruling does not legalise the collective camp.
Lisbon’s Administrative Court sided on Sunday with one member of the housing protest camp. Renata Cambra may spend the night in Rossio, in a tent, until 24 November, the date set for the final vote on Portugal’s 2027 State Budget.
The ruling landed a few hours after police cleared the Lisbon and Porto camps for the third time in the early hours of the same Sunday, detaining 13 people.
The half-past-midnight question
Portugal’s 1974 law on public assemblies sets 12.30am as the limit for protests on the street. It is the rule the PSP police leaned on each time it ordered the tents down. The judge found that the limit is neither absolute nor automatic. It cannot simply be applied the same way to every case.
So Cambra can be in Praça D. Pedro IV between 12.30am and 6.30am, with a tent, until budget day. There is one condition attached: the protest has to fit around the Christmas market planned for the same square.
What the ruling leaves out
This is the part worth reading twice. The court did not rule on whether a collective occupation of Rossio is lawful, and it did not recognise any general right to pitch tents in public space for an unlimited number of people. The permission covers one protester and one tent.
That is also what she asked for. Her urgent petition, filed on 20 October against the Interior Ministry and Lisbon City Council, asked that the PSP and municipal police not stop her or remove her tent until the morning of 25 November. The council argued she had no standing to defend the protest as a whole. Cambra leads the small Trabalhadores Unidos party and is one of the camp’s participants.
What happens next
Neither the government nor the council had responded by early Monday afternoon, and it is not yet known whether either will appeal. The right to protest without prior permission sits in Article 45 of Portugal’s Constitution, and the tension between that and the 1974 time limit is now firmly in front of the courts.
The calendar keeps it in the news for three more weeks. The budget cleared its first vote on 28 October, and the camp picked the final vote as its finish line from day one.
Illustration: Tugadaily